In the world of BJJ there is the constant argument of guard pulling vs take downs. Let’s discuss something more specific, guard pulling vs sacrifice throws since there is a similarity between the two.
Below is the standard guard pull by obtaining a grip and sitting to the ground to immediately establish a competitor’s strongest position. Below is Paulo Miyao doing this to Alexandre Souza.
This type of guard pulling above is illegal in most other sports such as Judo and Sambo. Now on the other side we have the Yoko Tomoe Nage preformed below by Francisco Maciel. This is known as a sacrifice throw Judo because a person is using their own falling body to perform a throw.
Why is the sacrifice throw and variations of it underutilized in BJJ and guard pulling has become more universal? Some would argue against this because there is greater risk in pulling a sacrifice throw, such as having it misdirected and having your guard passed immediately. Others argue that this would make guard pulling much more entertaining and can lead directly into submissions off the bat.
What are your opinions?
Edit: Article was also featured on BJJEE